Watch Nostalgia Critic Nightmare Videos

The Nightmare Before Christmas - Nostalgia Critic

Nostalgia Critic Commentary: Let's Play Bart's Nightmare

Let's Play: Bart's Nightmare - Nostalgia Critic

The Nightmare Critic

Nightmare As A Child - Twilight-Tober Zone

Dreamcatcher - Nostalgia Critic

Is Nightmare Before Christmas Really That Great?

Nightmare Before Christmas - Disneycember

RE: Nostalgia Critic's Barts Nightmare LP

Nostalgia Critic Let's Play Barts Nightmare...in 5 seconds.

OneyPlays Clip - Nostalgic Critic and the Muppets (THE SIMPSONS: BART'S NIGHTMARE)

Poor Critic | Nostalgia Critic's version of 'Poor Jack'

The Grinch (2018) - Nostalgia Critic

Freddy vs Jason - Nostalgia Critic

9 - Nostalgia Critic

The Muppet Christmas Carol - Nostalgia Critic

Nostalgia Critic Commentary Let's Play Bart's Nightmare

The Witches - Nostalgia Critic

A Christmas Carol - Nostalgia Critic

Teddy Ruxpin Halloween Special - Nostalgia Critic